While
watching this movie, I found the individual versus community question to be in
my head a lot. What's interesting is that the Precrime justice system is being
advertised as a protective tool for both the community as a whole (the kids at
the ending of the advertisement), as well as for the individual (all of the
people saying where they would have been stabbed or whatever). However, the consequences of
Precrime directly affect the individual; when a pre-criminal is
caught and haloed, they are put into an eternal sleep-like state that seems far
from what would be in a utopic setting. This punishment also calls into
question the morality of this system and where it falls on the spectrum of being
autonomous versus having more laws and governance. Of course, both of these
versus are from the “Plotting Utopia” chart—I find myself going back to this
with Minority Report as I find it hard
to place in the quadrants. While the government is very adamant about
preventing/catching murder, they don’t seem to care much about other crimes
being committed. So, there could be a fair amount of autonomy in the society,
considering other laws aren’t focused on in the movie, but it could just be
that the government is just overlooking crimes that don’t involve homicide… And
then, again, with the happiness of the individual versus of the community—where
does Minority Report’s D.C. society
fall of this scale? I want to say somewhere in the middle since the community
is being protected at the cost of some individuals (but there’s still debate in
my head over that as well). Basically, this movie poses some strong moral
questions and has some serious punishment laws... Where would you place it in the
plot?
No comments:
Post a Comment